Here is prolific contributor Peggy Dobbs’ second entry into our A Dish Called “Wanda” contest.  She examines complicated family ties, the push and pull of filial love, and the responsibility which falls heavily on the shoulders of children who feel an uncomfortable reversal of roles as they care for those who once cared for them.

************************************

Dried Rose Petals on the Floor

She never had any children of her own. It seems almost cruel, yet her kind of love was too possessive to raise a child. It was the kind of love that did not know how to say “NO!” There was never a child of any race or color that she didn’t love instantly and they, in return, sensed that love and returned it.

I was an only child and my mother resented the fact that her sister-in-law thought I belonged to her. I felt like a wish bone. My aunt pulling and wishing I was hers and my mother pulling, confident I belonged to her. There was a quiet dislike between them from the beginning of their relationship. My birth fed flames of dislike with jealousy like a hot iron left on warm ultimately leaves the imprint of a scorched outline.

My aunt told wonderful stories to me, my children and their children. One of our favorites that we insisted she tell over and over began, “The locals warned me about Wanda’s, but why was there anything for me to be afraid of?  They didn’t know that Wanda’s looked like a very scary place on the outside to keep adults away, but since I loved children so much, I was allowed to be the door keeper.  Children knew that Wanda’s was the door way to a magical land that only the children and I could see.”  From that point, the story would differ with each particular child.

She lived to be ninety and for a few months, I tried to take care of her in my home.  With her mind slipping, the nurses where she had been living, told me it would be too much for me to handle.

It was!

I had to return her to the nursing facility for my own health’s sake. She lived there until she died. But her love and her stories still live in the hearts of all the children her life touched.  One day when my perceived failure caused the inevitable guilt to surface, these words erupted:

Who is this old person who lies in this bed, who demands my attention and demands to be fed.

Who asks where I’m going and when I’ll return.

Who wants what she wants with no care for the ruin of any other life on this vast planet earth.

Has she been this way always…this way since her birth?

Who is this old person who lies in this bed as she’s viewed by my aging eyes, in my graying head?

This caregiver’s not old, but neither is she young.

In caring for this old person, is there no joy left to be sung?

If only I could remember before age took its toll,

Through the mind of a child before this loved one got old.

Who is this old person who lies in this bed?

Did she rock me and tell stories and see I was fed?

Did she take me to town and gently pinch on my cheek?

Did we really have tea parties at her house once a week?

I wish I could remember. It all happened…but when?

Through the mind of a child, I need to go back there again.

Who is this old person who lies in this bed?

Surely, my childish recall can’t already be dead.

But I do remember with clarity, she told me one day,

“You can know you did all you could, when I’ve gone away.”

So as I look at her there in such a wrinkled up state,

Seeking the mind of a child, I know is too late.

This old person here, who lies in this bed

Has all rights to her dignity and it must always be said

That she was cared for and loved because she had worth.

It’s her right as a person, but in me, there is no more mirth,

As I watch while she withers like dried rose petals fallen to the floor.

Through the mind of a child, the one I loved so…is not here anymore.

*******************************

Editor’s Note: I watched my own grandmother – a rather memorable personality – slowly transformed by age into someone less and less like the person I knew as a child.  Maybe, when someone you love dies, there’s always a feeling that you could have done more; the truth is, we do the best we can at the time.

 
About The Author

spykergyrl

I'm just a gyrl.

  • Mac Eagan

    What a beautiful piece, Peggy. It looks like you took your time working in “the line” and how you did so was brilliant. In the story, but not really part of the story. A piece of 'set dressing, ' if you will, that contributes well to the overall image without taking center stage and distracting from the true star, the fond memories of a beloved aunt. This may be my favorite from you so far.

  • Dave Fisher

    Wow, you really captured it. I watched that happen to my father, we did everything together when I was a child and then as an adult. Little by little the years took their toll and then he was gone. Reading this was like a trip to the past. Very nicely done.

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Thank you Dave. I think you have to go through it, to truly know it. I hope the “trip to the past” was a bitter sweet one. Blessings, pd

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Mac I appreciate you taking the time to read it. Your comments always have good points that are constructive, but when you start that second sentence, “In the story, but not really part”, are you talking about the poem? I assume that is what you mean. If so that was what I was aiming for. I did that in one other piece I wrote, “It's All Been Sung.” Many thanks, pd

  • Star5fallonmyheart

    I don't know if I told you this…but my maternal grandfather has Alzheimer's. His mind has slowly been going for several years now and no longer knows who I am anymore. My matneral grandmother can attest to the misery that accompanies caring for a loved one with this disease.

    Everything you said in the poem is right. You look at this person, trying to find the person you once knew, but when you look in their eyes, you're lucky if you see a stranger instead of complete emptiness. My grandfather and your aunt are/were no longer the same people we grew up knowing. As much as it kills me to think of the day I'll finally get the dreaded phone call, the only comfort I'm sure I'll feel is that he'll be in heaven, immersed in God and everything in his life will finally make sense. But until then…

    This was a wonderful piece. Certainly touching to those who have loved ones who are chronically ill. Once again, your impeccable choice in rhyme blows me away. Keep on writing Peggy =)

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    I knew this would touch you and I hope you tuck a copy away until that day…
    We have a kinship in a strange sort of way and as I was typing this to send in, it was you I thought of and wondered what your comment would be. Thank you for understanding, as I knew you would and for your kind words in the way it was written. Blessings, pd

  • Mac Eagan

    Actually, I was referring to the line “The locals warned me…” which the aunt used to start the favorite stories. Because her stories ended differently each time, the beginning could have been anything. Most of the submissions in this contest hinge on “the locals warned me.” It becomes a critical piece of the writing. Your usage did not have it as a critical piece, but it was also not forced in to satisfy the rulebook. It was cleverly woven into the fabric of the story, but the real story had nothing to do with Wanda. The story was about the love of two family members.

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Well, so much for Wanda. We don't have to be concerned about her anymore. Thanks Mac. pd

  • http://www.awordwithyoupress.com/ Thornton Sully

    But then again you never know when the editor-in-chief might wanda back in with some frivolous comment, just to prove he reads your entries in between smoking fat cigars.

    Timing was good for me with this story, as I mentioned I just lost someone this week to the unfairness of old age.

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Dear Whomever-in-chief,
    Believe it or not, I knew you would pop up when I wrote what I did to Mac about Wanda. I just knew! You just answered more quickly than I expected. I have never told you that one of my spiritual gifts is a type of “discernment” or at times pre-cognition. It was really working this morning. I wouldn't be surprised to know that you have a direct link to everything written on this site.
    Seriously, you did tell me about your friend's mother. I hate cancer! She couldn't have been very old. I hope something in the poem was of comfort to anyone who needed it. But its not just old age that isn't fair. Scott Peck began his book “The Road Less Traveled” with the observation that life is not fair! And if you don't quit smoking those “fat cigars” you are not going to be able to blame what happens on the unfairness, you know better! Love ya, pd

  • http://www.awordwithyoupress.com/ Thornton Sully

    (I put this in parentheses to keep it a secret–I don't smoke. don't tell. ruins the Hemingway image I am cultivating. I do intend to clog my arteries with generous amounts of your fried chicken one of these days, so it aint as if I don't live dangerously)

  • Star5fallonmyheart

    Awww I'm sorry Thorn =(

  • Rainyday10001

    This one was interesting but i feel like you could have added more detail to your story.

  • http://www.facebook.com/david.boop David Boop

    Okay, wow! That was sad, but real. The flow was pretty good towards the end. Good luck in the contest!

  • Steve7k

    Peggy you're a star. i could do my usual pointing out of a couple of punctuation bits, but it the technical bits don't matter. It's moving, involving and, like everyone else has commented, really focuses the mind on love, death, old age and the feeling of helplessness. My mum died in 2004 of cancer. Watching her get smaller and smaller was a hell of a thing to go through. My partner's now going through chemotherapy and that's all going to be fine, but your story really brought the whole lot together – the person who's suffering through the illness and the one who's there 'suffering' but in silence; wanting to do whatever s/he can, but not wanting to cause upset or show their own worry, but knowing there's a point when you can't do any more because it's out of your control.

    If evoking emotion were an Olympic event you'd have a gold.

    Steve

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Steve, I havn't been back to this site in a while so I just read your comment. I felt your pain and your sincerity. With love, always comes pain. But, oh…it's so worth it. Thank you for taking the time to share what you have been through and are going thorough. I pray you friend will continue to heal.
    Blessings, pd

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    Thank you for the critique, and if Thorn wasn't so stingy with his word count, I would have. Seven hundred and Fifty just ain't much! Blessings, pd

  • Peggy R. Dobbs

    David, Thank you for what I hoped would be “real” in such a touching situation. Wish you would elaborate on the rest of your comment. Anything to make it better would be appreciated. Blessings, pd

  • http://www.awordwithyoupress.com/ Thornton Sully

    That's right. Blame me.