Literati!

I thank you all for being soooo patient as we brought this one in for a landing.  The Second Annual Victor Villasenor  First Sentence Contest comes to an end, and we can get on with our summer! The whole idea of the contest was to stress the importance of your first words to your readership, your one and only first impression, your chance to seduce, cajole, bully, persuade, or otherwise entice your reader to go further. It was the best of times; it was the worst of times.  Call me Ishmael. In the beginning, there was the word. December tumbled out of storm cloud passing over the island on its way to Los Angeles.

All instantly recognizable first lines to great works. I still remember the first line to Macho, Victor Villasenor’s first published novel, after of course it received 265 rejections before it was taken by a majot publisher. “They, the family, lived in a house built of mud and sticks.”  (Fact checkers out there–you know who you are– I have not seen that book in thirty years.  Tell me if my memory serves me well.) Victor, our neighbor here in Oceanside and best seller of works including Rain of Gold, The Wild Steps of Heaven, and The Thirteen Senses, is the inspiration for this contest, which of course we will repeat next year.

So this exercise was intended to bring home the importance of that first line, and when we had so many that were so good, it seemed reasonable to have a write off for finalists, and give them liberty to expand the first line into a story.  For those of you just coming to us for the first time, the hitch was that the first line the finalists used had to be someone else’s first line, someone  else who had entered the competition other than a finalist.

We have started a tradition here at A Word with You Press. Although it means Derek and I are no longer in a position to accept bribes (loved the chocolate, by the way) we now have each new contest judged by the winner of the previous contest. That means that the man who accepted offers of cash, a job, chocolate booze, or a date with you, your daughter, your son, your wife, your husband, or your German shepherd was Jon Tobias.  We have no idea what won him over. Perhaps it was just damn good writing.

And here are his conclusions:

I don’t even know where to start. I have read these so many times I think I might have memorized them. So before I get any further in explaining my experience as judge, I am just going to jump into it.

Mike Stang-Thief- Your story takes us through the darkness of another man’s soul. More importantly it leaves us feeling guilty for wanting to know more about that darkness, wanting to go on that journey with him. Then there’s the man in the traffic, is he the narrator’s old self, perhaps the old self that never came to be? There is so much mystery to it I want more! That is what good writing does to us.

(here is the link to his story:www.awordwithyoupress.com/2011/06/26/take-away-my-heartachetake-away-my-grief-take-away-my-sorrow/

Maleeha Ahmad-Criminal, Geeks and Starbucks- It’s always interesting to see where a first line can lead the imagination and this version is no exception. In these times I wouldn’t be surprised to see a headline “Wanted Criminal Caught thanks to Starbucks Obsession”. It is quirky and strangely believable.

(here is the link www.awordwithyoupress.com/2011/06/26/kyle-katz-is-a-sentence-donor/

Janet Klise-The Shard- This is hauntingly poetic. It breaks my heart every time I read it. Every time there is a little more. First I just noticed the way the words flowed, then the story, then the story behind the story. How this is about a woman who lost a child and she is “fighting back the cold” to keep a garden alive with the blankets. Then there’s the double meaning when she speaks about all the repairs that still need to be done. And the line, “Was it like another naked place?” is just beautiful. The subtlety is heart wrenching and the imagery is beautiful. Then the end, with her weapon in hand, we have just enough idea to see what she is going to do, and my heart finally breaks. Just amazing.

(and the link:www.awordwithyoupress.com/2011/06/30/the-dog-ate-my-homework/)

Paige Adams Strickland-Untitled- Did you not title it on purpose? Maybe to add to the frustration I felt when I was only allowed to see the date on the envelope. I mean talk about cliff hangers. You knew what you were doing the whole time, and somehow I think you’ve been there, with the bottles and the cokes and the box hidden behind them. You captured a moment I think all of us have been to. And for that reason I am truly fine with not knowing what is in that envelope. You captured a moment in time, when we were all breathless, trying to get to something we were never supposed to see. It never mattered what happened when we finally peeled back the label and at the same time caught our breath because it was always the same feeling. Only writers who have truly mastered their craft can do that and get away with it. You are one of those writers.

(the link to her story:  www.awordwithyoupress.com/2011/06/26/prerogotives-caught-exercising-at-hq/)

And finally, what you all have been waiting for, the winner.

I chose Peggy Dobbs’ story. One of These Days starts off as a dream, then becomes a memory, then it also becomes an inevitable future. Your story spans 2 generations. We saw a man who rode a bull and died because of it. This man’s son is destined to do the same at any cost. The man’s wife, the boy’s mother, we know will be forced to watch them both die. The reason that I chose this story was actually because of the last line. It suggests a much longer story where we already know the ending. These characters are so real and so strong in their intentions we might have seen this story unfold a hundred times. It is strong and tightly woven from beginning to end. There is no mystery or unanswered questions. It is perfectly rounded and for me does exactly what a story should do. Even though I know what’s coming, and am still glued and sucker-punched anyway.

Congratulations.

A Word with You Press will be sending Peggy a signed copy of Victor Villasenor’s latest work Beyond Rain of Gold and a Barnes and Nobel Gift card for $50.

Here is her winning story, based on a first sentence submitted by Gary Clark.

ONE OF THESE DAYS

“You son of a bitch! You’re not going to beat me. I’ve been beat by a few of the best but your’re not one of ‘em.”

Cody didn’t know whether he had actually yelled the words or just thought  ‘em  as the rodeo crowd rose to their feet in anxious expectation, some yelling for the rider, some yelling for the bull. Cody didn’t care. Today, he was a Cowboy  Gladiator and he was the center of attention in the middle of the dust filled Coliseum, wanting to give rodeo groupies enough thrills so they would remember him, “Cody Hayes”, when he swaggered off in his skin tight, faded jeans that never hit the ground and his snug fitting, Justin Ostrich boots. He’d be grinning and waving the winning purse in the same rope bound hand that kept him and this tormented bull tied to each other like a cow with a calf whose umbilical cord was wrapped around its neck, not breathing, birthing breech.

The crowd was now hollering, “Cody, Cody, Cody”! They could see day light between him and the bull each time “Damnation” invented a new way to get rid of this foreign thing on his back. Cody was sure he could feel the fire from snot flaring out of the bull’s nose and he knew most of the rodeo crew had odds bet on Damnation winning this mortal battle. But they were going to lose! “O, God, please let them lose!” he prayed, as Damnation dug in his front hoofs and Cody was air borne, the ground coming up to meet him and blood everywhere!

He woke tangled in the sheet and the quilt his grandma Hayes had made him for Christmas. Laying on his back between his bed and the chest-of-drawers, his feet were frailling the air groping for ground, anything solid, anything real!  He was just realizing where he was when the door opened and his mother rushed toward him crying, “Cody, Cody, you alright, Hon? What happened? Here, let me help you get up!” He slapped her hands away and the minute his thirteen year old brain realized what he had done, he threw his arms around her, apologizing for his rough response.

She sat back on the floor, leaning against the wall, realizing what he must have been dreaming. It had happened before. The love of her life, Cody’s Dad, had been a prize winning rodeo rider who gave his life on a blazing hot day when Cody was six years old. Cody had been there with her when her husband had been crushed under the hooves of a bull named, Damnation. Her worst fear was that her only child would follow the same, dusty, endless trail and there was nothing she could do about it. Sighing, with tears on her cheeks, she brushed the familiar black hair out of his sky blue eyes, so like his Dad’s, as he whispered to her, “One of these days, Mom.”

****************************

 
About The Author

Thornton

Someday, I'll get it write...

  • Anonymous

    Well…..Son of a Bitch! 

  • Anonymous

    You’re a hoot! See, if it hadn’t been for your first line, I wouldn’t have won so you can be the next judge! Thank you for letting me use your attention- getter. Blessings, Peggy

  • L.S. Parkson

    Well done, Peggy! I love your character development and rich emoti0n. You are a gifted story teller.
    Cheers,
    L.S.

  • Anonymous

    Jon,
    This is my first win and I don’t envy replacing you as Judge.  More importantly, I  really have no words to express my gratitude for the amazing way you summarized my story.

     To Gary’s and Mike’s surprise, I knew immediately which “first line” I would steal, Gary Clark’s, when I became a finalist and after that the story sorta wrote itself. You saw things in it that I had not even noticed. All I knew was that I liked the story myself and that is the only way that I know how to write.

     Again, thank you for all the time I know you must have put into this and thank you to Mr. Victor Villasenor for providing “this game” for Thorn’s “playground”.
    Blessings, Peggy Dobbs

  • Anonymous

    Thank you for reading it and for your kind words.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    I had to think for a few minutes what you had written, but then I remembered that it reminded me of The Girl Who Kicked The Hornets Nest. I wish I had a name to the L.S., but from someone who writes as well as you do, your opinion is really appreciated. Thank you.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Yeahhhhhhhhhhh Peggy!  Competition was tough. Five stories, all truly great in their own individual style and voice, showing clearly why those authors were chosen for the final five, and you won!  

    Jon – you done good, boy!  I bet you emptied that Elvis Decanter three or four times wrestling with these stories and finally finding one thing that caused the winner to rise above the rest. Damn good job!  Ain’t fun is it?

    Thorn will send you your 24K gold AWwYP Judge’s medal real soon. I got mine and was so proud of it, I got it BRONZED!

  • Janet Klise

    Congrats to you, Peggy, on your much-deserved win. Good story!!!
    It was an honor to be a finalist among such a group of fine, fine writers.
    And good luck to Judge Peggy!

  • George Verongos

    PEGGY!!!! You rock!
    This is a great story very real and great details. I was almost choking on the dust. Huzzah!!!

  • Paige Adams Strickland

    Peggy:  Congratulations!  You had an amazing story.

    To everyone else, thank you so much for the welcome to the circle. 

    Jon: Thank you for the awesome and detailed review of my story…As to why I didn’t have a title…I honestly think I missed putting in a title!  I’m a newbie and didn’t yet know…I also didn’t know if it counted in the word count, and I needed every last word for just the story!  It’s based on an experience my sister had. I can’t say for sure if it was exactly the way it happened for her. I can only guess since I wasn’t there when it happened. (I was in my adoptive home, and she was with our birthmother.) The guy who guessed adoption papers was pretty accurate!  My birthmother swiped papers out of her medical chart after I was born, and she could get up and around. That’s what my sister found about 9 years later.

    Thanks again for having me!  Hope to enter another contest at another time!   Paige

  • M. Stang

    I see now that I should have gone with Gary’s opener, but, alas, that is all in the past.  Ms. Peg, I am walking on air, knowing you have been chosen.  I have said before I was swinging with a pro.  All of the finalists came to win, all of them had something to say; something important.  You, my dear lady, said it best.  Enjoy!

  • M. Stang

    When the hell did you get that?  I didn’t get one and I drank more of Bucatti’s scotch than any elvis bottle

  • M. Stang

    Jon thank you for sticking to the task.  Peggy truely was great.

  • http://twitter.com/DerekWriteLines Derek Thompson

    Well done Peggy! A great story of a family in crisis, where the chains of destiny drag a young boy kicking and screaming to his fate. He’s as imprinted as a newborn chick, and his mother knows it.

  • Jon Tobias

    Man, I always go for beer when times ‘er tough. I went through a lot of IPA. Still flushing it out by the way.

  • Anonymous

    You three are not making this “Judging” business any easier for me! I tried to volunteer out of this position for someone who would make a more qualified judge, but you know that guy that runs this place, and he that makes the rules, it seems, changes them only for him-moi! Any advice you guys can give me, I’m all ears. 
    Thank you for being such faithful readers and writers. pd

  • Anonymous

    Derek, so good to hear from you way over there in Corwall! I remember that you liked the line where I used the “chain rusted itself into view”, I like yours better, “chains of destiny drag a young boy”, great! Thank you for your comment.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Paige, I hope you feel at home among us now. I remember how scary it was to send in the first story on this site. I didn’t even know that the computer would count for me. In that particular story, Thorn had said in the instructions that the title didn’t count, and I was like you, I needed every word. I hope you will write in the next contest, I’ll be looking for your entry. Thank you for your kind words.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    George, that sounds like a rebel yell, sure you aren’t a Southerner? So glad I chose words “real” enough to make you feel them. Thanks,
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Janet, I agree that it was honor enough to just be among this five! Your praise is icing on the cake. Hope to read your next story and am able to be as objective as possible with them all.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Mike, you are always so encouraging to me. Your story was, as I told you before, way out there on the edge. I hope that I can do you Sci-fis justice as a judge. Please know that I’ll give it my best shot. I have mentioned several times how I welcomed you to this site. I hunted that comment down and I still mean every word.
    Blessings, pd
    ps. Is Sci-fi correct, Mac?

  • Stars Fall On My Heart

    Finally indeed <3 Love you MzPapa!!!

  • http://branch92.com FJDagg

    Congratulations, Peggy, on a well-deserved win! IMO, this is your best yet, and that’s saying a lot. You paint a vivid picture of Cody on the cusp between boyhood and manhood, suffering between the crushing weight of the past and the irresistable gravity of the future. So grim, yet beautifully poignant.

  • Mac Eagan

    Congratulations, Peggy!
    What I was most interested in watching during the “finalizing” of this contest was how each writer would take someone else’s words and re-direct them into their own.  What I didn’t expect was for someone to adapt their own voice to fit the first line.
    Cowboys and rodeos aren’t the first things that come to my mind when I think ‘stories by Peggy Dobbs.’  And yet you successfully captured the tone and attitude I would expect for just such a story.  If someone had tagged Gary’s name on this entry, I never would have questioned it.  You have shown yourself to be very versatile as a story-teller and a writer.
    Don’t stress yourself out about the judging responsibility . . . yet.  Wait until the new rules come out and see what the challenges and standards are going to be.  Then, perhaps, you can worry.
    Finally – “sci-fi’s?”  I am not sure I really understand the question I am being asked.

  • Diane Cresswell

    Its official – you are now the Cowgirl.  Congratulations.  You took Gary’s words, which were great, and made it into your own. And it all fits.  Only the mistress of the art of writing can wing it with words from another.  To all the others, congrats on your entries.  I would have had a terrible time trying to pick one.  To Jon – you did a great job.  All the stories were fascinating, imagiinative and cliff hanging.  We do have some very good writers Thorn.  Now on to the next one…I raise my beverage to all of you.  Peggy you are the best.!

  • Jvandendorp

    Congratulations Peggy! Your story flows beautifully, but the end seems really the beginning of the story of Cody’s life, coping with the death of his father.
    I liked that through his dream/nightmare, we learn the details of his father’s death.  When Cody’s mother leans against the wall, I feel the years of her inner battles.  The last paragraph speaks volumes about the lives of these two characters. I am not surprised you won; this one is on a new level. Felicitaciones :) )
    Juan

  • Anonymous

    Juan,
    You just don’t know how much you are missed on this site! You were the first winner that I remember, but that was before the winner had to be the next judge. Your opinion has always been very important to me, so thank you so much for reading my story and commenting.
    Blessings to you and to your new business. pd

  • M. Stang

    Tis I now, with tears.  Once again and forever-congratulations on a well won contest.  Ask Gary about Texas Lit magazines, send the story out, get it featured somewhere.  Defintely strong enough.  Keep writing PD.

  • M. Stang

    That’s a little more information than we need to know but hey, I get how this judging works.  The thing is, as I see it, the stakes have raised.  Mr. Sully and Mr. Thompson have taken themselves out of the role.  We writers are far more criticle of each other when it comes to first place then we care to admit and it can be a crap shoot but that’s okay, like Thorn says he’s not getting paid and neither are we.  He could close us down tonight.  So let’s dance while there’s still time.
    Chances are good my nephew made that IPA, he works for Firestone. Honest to injun Jon, I never told him to put something extra in your bottles.

  • Anonymous

    Diane, You are so faithful to comment on everyone’s writing and I’m sure the others appreciate it as much as I do. I am going to be looking forward to what you write next time. Hope I can do half as well as the other Judges have done. Also, thanks for keeping my self confidence up enough to keep me plugging away at writing. 
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Mac,
    You along with Jon brought out some things I had not noticed about my own story. I didn’t realize that I had taken on the voice that Gary would have used, but since you pointed it out, I see that it is true. Gary and Mike both said they were surprised that I chose that first line since it isn’t in my vocabulary. But I just did what seemed natural to me to do, unaware I was doing it. I’ve told you before you really bring a lot to the table with your comments and I always try to take them to heart.

    What I was asking was, what is the genre called when the writers write about vampires and out of space and time reality, Science-fiction?
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    You are another one that we miss hearing from, James. I know you are busy  getting your book out before the public, but we really miss you and Juan. Thank you for taking the time to read my story and comment on it. It is very encouraging for us unpublished writers to hear from those who have finaleeeeeeeeee made it!
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Steph, 
    How sweet you are to remember what my grandchildren call me. And what a surprise to hear from you. I was so afraid you were writing on another site now. You were already on this site when I came along. Your stories and comments are from a talent that lessens us by our not having the opportunity to hear from you. I hope things are going well for you.
    Love and Blessings, mzp

  • Mac Eagan

    Genres used to be simple.  It seems now they have become so specific in some instances that it is hard to keep up.
    Science Fiction, or sci-fi, is fiction with a strong scientific element.  Computers, robots, space travel, time travel – all and more qualify.  Vampires, witches, ghosts and the like are often linked with sci-fi, but I believe are a specific sub-genre, also referred to as fantasy or paranormal.

  • Jon Tobias

    You should tell him to add a lil somethin. I wouldn’t mind. You are so very right my friend. This has been one of the most amazing experiences I have ever had. I am dancin’ dancin’ dancin’ my good sir.

  • Chuck

    Congratulations, Peggy. Well done.

  • Kyle katz

    Peggy, this is exceptional writing. It’s vivid and immediate action puts me in the stands, cheering for Cody. The many twist and turns of emotions , catches me by surprise and delights all my senses as a reader. I love it.

  • Anonymous

    Kyle, thank you for your encouragement. I was hoping to cause those kinds of emotions. Funny, sometimes when you are writing, you can actually feel them yourself. It was that way with me while writing this story. I really liked the people.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Thank you Chuck. I appreciate you taking the time to comment.
     Blessings, pd

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sable-Jordan/100001028960287 Sable Jordan

    Congrats, Peggy! And to everyone who entered. Recently read all of the finalists and they’re all exceptional! Write on!

  • Tlrelf

    Congratulations! Now turn it into a prize-winning novel. . .

  • http://monicabrinkmanbooks.webs.com Monica M. Brinkman

    Congratulations Peggy. I sent my final entry in but didn’t hear back about it and check in today and found you had won. I see why. Very well done.

    Monica M. Brinkman

  • Anonymous

    Monica, I’m sure it was a disappointment to find out the contest was over. Thorn well may still publish your story. Thank you for your congrats.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Monica, I’m sure it was a disappointment to find out the contest was over. Thorn well may still publish your story. Thank you for your congrats.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Believe it or not, (is it Terri?) I have already written the first chapter. Wish I had more time to spend on it. Thank you for reading and commenting.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Believe it or not, (is it Terri?) I have already written the first chapter. Wish I had more time to spend on it. Thank you for reading and commenting.
    Blessings, pd

  • Anonymous

    Sable, Is this your first time to leave a comment? I remember reading your comments on Thorn’s FB wall, but thank you for the encouragement from all of us finalists. Hope you will stick around. 
    Blessings, pd